Appreciating the near-perfection of ‘Homeland’

Damian Lewis and Claire Danes in 'Homeland' -- Photo courtesy of Showtime
Damian Lewis and Claire Danes in ‘Homeland’ — Photo courtesy of Showtime

It’s hard to live in America without having watched Homeland, the award-winning Showtime series that recently completed its second season. There are so many conversations among friends, families and colleagues about the provocative show that it’s must-see television around the water-cooler.

My confession: I only recently finished watching season 1 on DVD. I’m a little behind on the fury, but I can easily understand why the adventures of Carrie Mathison (Claire Danes) and Nicholas Brody (Damian Lewis) have so transfixed TV viewers. The show has taken so many refreshingly compelling steps for a serialized drama, and that’s a rare thing in the world of television. How many shows have gone astray — Dexter, anybody? How many shows have ticked off audiences — The Killing, anybody?

Homeland only disappoints in its momentary glimpses of incomplete perfection. While watching season 1, it was obvious that the show is some of the best television in the marketplace. However, it never achieves perfection. This is somewhat disappointing, but not enough for any of us to turn away. These slight imperfections mostly come in the middle of the inaugural season when (spoiler alert!) Mathison and Brody have a tryst at a cabin in the woods. When the drama moves away from the goings-on of the CIA, it becomes overly melodramatic.

Aside from that momentary lapse, it has been a pleasure to watch Homeland. The plot is ripped from our news headlines, and the scripts are intelligent and beautifully written. Any time Mandy Patinkin (playing Saul Berenson) is on screen, the show flies sky high. He has an uncanny ability to deliver lines in such a serious, yet nonchalant, manner. It’s a performance rooted in reality, which helps a show that deals with internationally intense concepts that could easily stray into the land of furrowed brows (like Patinkin’s last TV show, Criminal Minds).

Danes, always an under-appreciated actress, is a great troubled heroine, a woman dealing with bipolar disorder and an increasingly frustrated top brass at the agency (headed by David Estes, played by David Harewood). She’s likable, yet terribly, terribly flawed. If we didn’t know of her difficulties both personally and professionally, we would probably hate Mathison. She breaks far too many rules and never paints within the lines. But, of course, this makes her a compelling character.

Lewis is good as Brody, although if there had to be a weak point in the casting department, it would have to be him. His steely stares and method style of acting never seem to fit. Some would say (and they would be partly right) that Brody is never supposed to fit in, given his questionable history and ties to terrorists. But this makes him a frustrating creation.

His family, including Morena Baccarin as his wife Jessica, feel similarly out of step. They’re just all right, and their inadequacies as characters are heightened because they find themselves in a stellar show.

That’s Homeland season 1 in a nutshell. It’s so good that we’re simultaneously aware of its strengths and slight weaknesses. I’ll try to focus on the strengths.

By John Soltes / Publisher /

  • Homeland, starring Claire Danes, Mandy Patinkin and Damian Lewis, airs on Showtime. Click here for more information.

John Soltes

John Soltes is an award-winning journalist. His writing has appeared in The New York Times, Earth Island Journal, The Hollywood Reporter, New Jersey Monthly and at, among other publications. E-mail him at

2 thoughts on “Appreciating the near-perfection of ‘Homeland’

  • December 25, 2012 at 3:42 pm

    I beg to disagree with you about the great actors on the show. Damian Lewis carries the show for me. The reason the show draws us in is his character, in the first place. I do not think I would have watched it if he was not in it. I cannot get into Mandy Patinkin. He is just OK for me, but I find him dull. Claire Danes is good in her part but appears to over act. Morena Baccarin plays her role excellently and given more lines, she would really shine.

  • January 1, 2013 at 9:43 am

    I have to disagree. I think the cast of Homeland is pretty much uniformly great. Damian Lewis I think has been phenomenal and does an incredible job making Brody seem so all-American and likable on the surface, yet at the same time showing this man is deeply untrustworthy and dangerous. Claire Danes of course is also fantastic, finally having a role worthy of her talent after so many wasted years acting in mediocre Hollywood crap. The surprising standout, for me, is Morena Baccarin. I think she’s been fantastic as Jessica, especially in the second season. She has made Jess a fully realized character, a woman whose life isn’t perfect but who has courage, spirit, and strength. After seeing Baccarin in V and now Homeland, I’m quite impressed with her range and skill as an actress.


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *